header-logo header-logo

Laying the blame

09 September 2010 / Sir Geoffrey Bindman KC
Issue: 7432 / Categories: Blogs
printer mail-detail

Why do lay judges get it wrong, asks Geoffrey Bindman

“What is truth?’ said jesting Pilate, and would not stay for an answer.” Bacon’s scepticism sums up the problem lawyers face all the time. What is it that persuades a judge to give one answer rather than another? Scholars argue whether there is always a “right” answer. Plainly different views are possible on matters of interpretation and judgment. The fair, just, humane result is often clear enough and trained judges usually find it. I have found in practice, however, that lay tribunals, especially in the academic and professional worlds, are prone to get it wrong.

Even where facts are plain the judicial response to them requires an evaluation of relative significance which involves issues of balance and proportion. When it comes to the consequential action to be directed by the judge, compassion, a sympathetic understanding of human nature, and sheer common sense come into play. When academics and members of the professions face disciplinary confrontations with their institutions, the bodies set up to adjudicate, consisting wholly or mainly of senior colleagues, frequently seem incapable of that dispassionate and

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

NLJ career profile: Liz McGrath KC

NLJ career profile: Liz McGrath KC

A good book, a glass of chilled Albarino, and being creative for pleasure help Liz McGrath balance the rigours of complex bundles and being Head of Chambers

Burges Salmon—Matthew Hancock-Jones

Burges Salmon—Matthew Hancock-Jones

Firm welcomes director in its financial services financial regulatory team

Gateley Legal—Sam Meiklejohn

Gateley Legal—Sam Meiklejohn Premium Content

Partner appointment in firm’s equity capital markets team

NEWS

Law school partners with charity to give free assistance to litigants in need

Magic circle firms, in-house legal departments and litigation firms alike are embracing more flexible ways to manage surges of workloads, the success of Flex Legal has shown

Magic circle firms, in-house legal departments and litigation firms alike are embracing more flexible ways to manage surges of workloads, the success of Flex Legal has shown

Magic circle firms, in-house legal departments and litigation firms alike are embracing more flexible ways to manage surges of workloads, the success of Flex Legal has shown

Walkers and runners will take in some of London’s finest views at the 16th annual charity event

back-to-top-scroll