header-logo header-logo

16 December 2022 / David Hewitt
Issue: 8007 / Categories: Features , Media , Defamation
printer mail-detail

Silent night (at the cinema)

104745
David Hewitt explores one of the most intriguing characters to emerge during the trial of the controversial Five Nights film

Of all the exotic characters to emerge during the Five Nights trial, none was more exotic than Sir Montague Shearman.

Mr Justice Shearman

The trial concerned a silent film that was at that moment outraging half the country (see ‘Shocks on screen: the case of Five Nights’, NLJ, 28 October 2022, p22), and Mr Justice Shearman, to give him his full title, was the presiding judge.

Born two decades into Queen Victoria’s reign, the son of a solicitor from Wimbledon, he went on to earn a ‘double-first’ degree from Oxford University. And though the men associated with the film included one who used a whip on his rivals, and another who would be sued by Charlie Chaplin, none of them would ever hold a candle to him.

‘Tont’ Shearman boxed and rowed, ran the 100 yards in barely ten seconds, and helped himself to a rugby blue. For a while, he was a member of the Wanderers,

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Jurit LLP—Caroline Williams

Jurit LLP—Caroline Williams

Private wealth and tax team welcomes cross-border specialist as consultant

Freeths—Michelle Kirkland Elias

Freeths—Michelle Kirkland Elias

International hospitality and leisure specialist joins corporate team as partner

Flint Bishop—Deborah Niven

Flint Bishop—Deborah Niven

Firm appoints head of intellectual property to drive northern growth

NEWS
Talk of a reserved ‘Welsh seat’ on the Supreme Court is misplaced. In NLJ this week, Professor Graham Zellick KC explains that the Constitutional Reform Act treats ‘England and Wales’ as one jurisdiction, with no statutory Welsh slot
The government’s plan to curb jury trials has sparked ‘jury furore’. Writing in NLJ this week, David Locke, partner at Hill Dickinson, says the rationale is ‘grossly inadequate’
A year after the $1.5bn Bybit heist, crypto fraud is booming—but so is recovery. Writing in NLJ this week, Neil Holloway, founder and CEO of M2 Recovery, warns that scams hit at least $14bn in 2025, fuelled by ‘pig butchering’ cons and AI deepfakes
After Woodcock confirmed no general duty to warn, debate turns to the criminal law. Writing in NLJ this week, Charles Davey of The Barrister Group urges revival of misprision or a modern equivalent
Family courts are tightening control of expert evidence. Writing in NLJ this week, Dr Chris Pamplin says there is ‘no automatic right’ to call experts; attendance must be ‘necessary in the interests of justice’ under FPR Pt 25
back-to-top-scroll