header-logo header-logo

25 November 2022 / Theo Huckle KC
Issue: 8004 / Categories: Features , Procedure & practice
printer mail-detail

Piecing together the puzzle

101335
How to tell who is telling the truth? Theo Huckle KC sets out some valuable guidance from the courts on assessing a witness’s honesty
  • In Muyepa v Ministry of Defence, Mr Justice Cotter dismissed a personal injury claim on the basis of fundamental dishonesty on the part of the claimant, and set out a useful step-by-step guide to analysing veracity.

Last year I wrote an article (blogged on my website (www.theohucklekc.com/blog)) about the Gestmin line of cases and the new practice direction (PD 57A) concerning certification of trial witness statements and extended statements of truth, and their implications for the proper judicial approach to assessing the credibility and veracity of witnesses.

Now, on his way to dismissing a personal injury claim on the basis that it was fundamentally dishonest, Mr Justice Cotter reconsidered this matter in detail in Muyepa v Ministry of Defence [2022] EWHC 2648 (KB), [2022] All ER (D) 71 (Oct) and provided a very helpful review of the issue of assessing lay evidence.

What was the background?

Mr Muyepa had

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Anthony Collins—20 promotions

Anthony Collins—20 promotions

20 promotions mark major people investment at national law firm, Anthony Collins

Sidley—Elaine Whiteford

Sidley—Elaine Whiteford

Sidley adds competition litigator Elaine Whiteford in London

Charles Russell Speechlys—Claudina D’Costa

Charles Russell Speechlys—Claudina D’Costa

Charles Russell Speechlys welcomes Claudina D’Costa as Director of Client Development Marketing

NEWS
The 25th Pro Bono Week begins today until 6 November, with events hosted by law firms, chambers, law schools and charities across the UK
Pro bono is celebrating a silver anniversary, with initiatives putting businesses and students at the heart of access to justice
Choosing the wrong expert can cost a clinical negligence claimant more than their case
Judges risk weakening their own independence by staying silent over government reforms, a leading public lawyer argues
A discount on damages does not automatically mean an equivalent haircut for legal costs in military deafness claims
back-to-top-scroll